You must be logged in to post

 
Search Forums:


 




Question: Brett Anderson or Trevor Cahill?

UserPost

1:24 pm
March 29, 2009


Phillies

Rookie

posts 17

1

I expect both of these guys to get a shot in the A's rotation with Duchscherer on the DL , but who do you guys think will do better this year and for future years. I think Anderson is the better pitcher and prospect but i would like some other opinions. Thanks

Phillies | Fantasy Baseball Xtreme | Moderator

2:18 pm
March 29, 2009


steelers0087

Moderator

posts 262

2

I like Brett Anderson for this year, I think he is more developed at this point.

Its hard to say who will be better in the future, but I have read that Cahill has more potential than Anderson.

Steelers0087 | Fantasy Baseball Xtreme Moderator

12:24 pm
April 3, 2009


steelers0087

Moderator

posts 262

3

Cahill is the #2 starter right now in that rotation.

Steelers0087 | Fantasy Baseball Xtreme Moderator

2:35 am
April 4, 2009


frankiephilly

Rookie

Philly

posts 103

4

Anderson also but I have to admit i dont know much about cahill. Anyone have good info on him or stats?

9:39 am
April 4, 2009


Phillies

Rookie

posts 17

5

I think he is the #2 guy in the rotation

Phillies | Fantasy Baseball Xtreme | Moderator

9:42 am
April 4, 2009


steelers0087

Moderator

posts 262

6

Phillies said:

I think he is the #2 guy in the rotation


Yes he is.

Cahill and Anderson are going to have a lot of bumps in the road this year. Dont expect anything consistent with these 2 SP all year long.

Steelers0087 | Fantasy Baseball Xtreme Moderator

4:44 pm
April 4, 2009


frankiephilly

Rookie

Philly

posts 103

7

steelers0087 said:

Phillies said:


I think he is the #2 guy in the rotation


Yes he is.

Cahill and Anderson are going to have a lot of bumps in the road this year. Dont expect anything consistent with these 2 SP all year long.


Thanks for the advice. Have any sleeper SPs to grab very late? In a draft now.

5:15 pm
April 23, 2009


steelers0087

Moderator

posts 262

8

Im liking both of these young SP's right about now. Great for dynasty pick-ups.

Anderson has been a little shaky but he showed what he can do against the red sox. 7 innings, 2 ER.

Steelers0087 | Fantasy Baseball Xtreme Moderator

12:43 pm
May 8, 2009


DarksideD

Rookie

posts 27

9

anderson has had some trouble out of the blocks  but he is the better pitcher    l,ooking forawrd

12:54 pm
May 15, 2009


steelers0087

Moderator

posts 262

10

DarksideD said:

anderson has had some trouble out of the blocks  but he is the better pitcher    l,ooking forawrd


Well see. Cahill is looking very impressive so far.

Steelers0087 | Fantasy Baseball Xtreme Moderator

2:48 pm
May 18, 2009


DarksideD

Rookie

posts 27

11

i think the lefty (anderson) has alot of upside   and has the tools to catch on with any staff down the line . he may not be major league ready right now  but he is learning while getting big league experience.

although brett anderson has had a miserbale start his walks total has been consistently low  which is somewhat encouraging


long term i think this left fairs better then cahill a guy who was never projected to be more then a 3-4 spot inthe rotation pitcher ,

7:35 am
May 23, 2009


Phillies

Rookie

posts 17

12

DarksideD said:

i think the lefty (anderson) has alot of upside   and has the tools to catch on with any staff down the line . he may not be major league ready right now  but he is learning while getting big league experience.

although brett anderson has had a miserbale start his walks total has been consistently low  which is somewhat encouraging


long term i think this left fairs better then cahill a guy who was never projected to be more then a 3-4 spot inthe rotation pitcher ,


well he already is #2

Phillies | Fantasy Baseball Xtreme | Moderator

11:43 am
July 20, 2009


steelers0087

Moderator

posts 262

13

Well, Anderson is on FIRE and Cahill isnt looking good at all.

Steelers0087 | Fantasy Baseball Xtreme Moderator

10:03 am
July 24, 2009


DarksideD

Rookie

posts 27

14

anderson has been progressing nicely and is owned in some larger mixed leagues .    he should be owned  if your in a long term dynasty league for sure

4:46 am
July 25, 2009


Dolemite

Moderator

posts 74

15

One more for anderson here!

Dolemite | Fantasy Baseball Xtreme Moderator

 
 

About the Fantasy Baseball Xtreme forum

Most Users Ever Online:

15


Currently Online:

5 Guests

Forum Stats:

Groups: 3

Forums: 9

Topics: 127

Posts: 843

Membership:

There are 48 Members

There has been 1 Guest

There are 4 Admins

There are 5 Moderators

Top Posters:

frankiephilly – 103

deweyc0x – 46

jakedogg187 – 39

Boston Dirtdogs – 28

cubforgood – 28

DarksideD – 27

Administrators: admin (0 Posts), garnett (0 Posts), smitty (130 Posts), takbax (0 Posts)

Moderators: Dolemite (74 Posts), junkyardjake (27 Posts), steelers0087 (262 Posts), Yarco (0 Posts), Zach (22 Posts)