Trying to upgrade in the OF…received the following offer:

I get Carl Crawford, Napoli, 2nd round pick

for

Joe Mauer, Brett Anderson, 1st round pick

Initial thoughts…I lose slightly on the player side of things…according to my rankings…which makes me really not like the draft pick part of the deal.  Would you do this deal as is, or consider it minus the draft pick swap?

Or would you not do this at all?  My current OF starters are probably Ellsbury, Rajai Davis and Swisher for the power…This would give me Ellsbury, Crawford, and either Davis or Swisher (and allow me to trade one of them possibly). 

Here is my roster as of right now:

Position Players
Joe Mauer Min C, DH
Jorge Posada NYY C, DH

Mark Teixeira NYY 1B
Paul Konerko CWS 1B, DH

Ian Kinsler Tex 2B
Chone Figgins Sea 2B

Kevin Youkilis Bos 1B, 3B

Asdrubal Cabrera Cle SS

Franklin Gutierrez Sea OF
Rajai Davis Tor OF
Jacoby Ellsbury Bos OF
Nick Swisher NYY OF
Alex Gordon KC OF

Luke Scott Bal DH

Pitchers
Brett Anderson Oak SP
Rick Porcello Det SP
James Shields TB SP
Dallas Braden Oak SP
Trevor Cahill Oak SP
Phil Hughes NYY SP
Fausto Carmona Cle SP
Dan Haren LAA SP

Rafael Soriano TB RP
Joakim Soria KC RP
JP Howell TB RP
Fernando Rodney LAA RP
Chris Perez Cle RP

Minor League Roster, followed by 2011 Baseball America Top 100 Rank
Desmond Jennings TB OF (22)
Josh Bell Bal 3B (major leagues)
Wil Myers KC C, OF (10)
Lonnie Chisenhall Cle 3B (25)
Zach Britton Bal LHP (28)