So this is how it is going to work.  I'm just going to post who I think deserves to be the All-Star for each position based on stats for 2011.  I will list standard 5x5 stats (runs, home runs, runs batted in, stolen bases, batting average for hitters;  wins, saves, strike outs, ERA, WHIP for pitchers), plus the original pre-season yahoo rankings along with the end of the year yahoo rank.  I will refrain from commentary here, may add that as time goes by with extra posts.  Feel free to disagree; I imagine 2B will be most debated, as well as the #3 SP an the #2 RP. 

C: Mike Napoli   72 – 30 –   75 –   4  - .320 From 115  to  58

1B: Adrian Gonzalez 108 – 27 – 117 –   1  - .338 From   12  to  10

2B: Dustin Pedroia 102 – 21 –   91 – 26  - .307 From   25  to  16

3B: Jose Bautista 105 – 43 – 103 –   9  - .302 From   35  to  12

SS: Troy Tulowitzki   81 – 30 – 105 –   9  - .302 From     3  to  28

OF: Ryan Braun 109 – 33 – 111 – 33  - .332 From     6  to    4

OF: Matt Kemp 115 – 39 – 126 – 40  - .324 From    19 to    1

OF: Jacoby Ellsbury 119 – 32 – 105 – 39  - .321 From    88 to    3

DH:  Curtis Granderson 136 – 41 – 119 – 25  - .262 From  101 to    6

SP: Justin Verlander 24 –   0 – 250 – 2.40 –   .92 From    59 to    2

SP: Clayton Kershaw 21 –   0 – 248 – 2.28 –   .98 From    33 to    5

SP: James Shields 16 –   0 – 225 – 2.82 – 1.04 From  210 to  17

RP: Craig Kimbrel   4 – 46 – 127 – 2.10 – 1.04 From  158 to  33

RP: Jose Valverde   2 – 49 –   69 – 2.24 – 1.19 From  126 to  69